Tuesday’s Quantico meeting wasn’t just a policy briefing. It was a political rally for a culture of cruelty.
Pete Hegseth, newly styled as “Secretary of War,” and President Trump promised a return to what they called the “warrior ethos.” They mocked the weak, dismissed diversity, and even loosened restrictions on hazing recruits.
Christians should hear alarm bells.
A Culture of Cruelty
Calling our nation’s fighting forces to be strong is one thing. Demanding that we discard compassion and deride the weak is another.
Scripture warns us that “those who live by the sword will die by the sword.” Elevating war as a cultural value, celebrating hazing, and sneering at the “politically correct” is not about defense, it’s about power for its own sake.
The move to rename the Department of Defense back to the “Department of War” is not just branding. Words shape the soul of a people. As a priest, I know that when you tell young recruits that they are warriors first and human beings second, you train them to see others not as neighbors but as enemies. We have seen where that road leads.
No one doubts the need for a disciplined, ready military. But discipline without mercy is brutality. Readiness without accountability is lawlessness. Christians are called to speak when our leaders confuse vengeance with justice.
The Wounded Knee Decision
Only days before his Quantico speech, Secretary Hegseth doubled down on that same distorted vision of warrior culture. He formally refused to rescind the Medals of Honor awarded to U.S. soldiers who slaughtered more than two hundred Lakota men, women, and children at Wounded Knee in 1890 — many of them unarmed and already surrendering.
To call those soldiers “brave” for killing people who had laid down their arms is to celebrate atrocity as heroism. That decision makes clear that what is being elevated is not courage in defense of others, but violence itself.
When we decorate massacres, we teach future generations that brutality is not only acceptable but praiseworthy. That is not a warrior ethos. It is the worship of the sword.
As Christians, we are not called to whitewash history or to repackage sin as valor. We are called to name our sins, repent of them, and do the hard work of making amends. The Gospel never asks us to glorify the shedding of innocent blood. To bless the slaughter of surrendered men, women, and children with a medal is to bless what Christ condemns. True strength is found in humility and in the courage to acknowledge wrongs, seek forgiveness, and work toward justice and reconciliation.
Mocking the Wounded
In his Quantico speech, Hegseth didn’t just promise sweeping standards—he went on to shame and degrade those who might fail them. He railed against “fat generals,” mocked what he called “unacceptable appearances,” and dismissed those who don’t meet his rigid idea of military bearing.
He insisted that anyone who “cannot pass a PT test or don’t want to shave and look professional, [should] get a new position or a new profession.” That’s a very poor example of leadership. That’s mockery.
Imagine being a soldier who gave your all, who sacrificed, but whose body, circumstances, or past injury makes Hegseth’s standard impossible. Under his rhetoric, you are not a hero who served—you’re a liability, or worse, a punchline.
Mocking those who fall short doesn’t raise rigor, it creates fear. It punishes the vulnerable. It demeans the dignity of every service member. And it sends the message that worth in the military depends only on physical perfection, not on sacrifice, loyalty, or character. As I’m to understand, today’s digital fighting forces don’t require physical human perfection, they require top notch training (Often very expensive training), and love of country.
A Policy That Targets Black Soldiers
Some of the harshest effects of Hegseth’s new grooming rules fall hardest on Black troops, especially those with pseudofolliculitis barbae (PFB)—a painful, chronic skin condition that makes daily razor shaving damaging or impossible.
This is not a rare problem. PFB disproportionately affects Black men, and for decades the military has offered shaving waivers so these troops can serve without scarring their faces.
Now those waivers are being rolled back. Troops who can’t meet the shaving rule are being told they must shave anyway—risking painful infections and scarring—or leave the service.
This is not about discipline. It is about forcing people to choose between pain and service. It is no wonder many see the new rule as discriminatory.
A standard that disproportionately harms one group of Americans—one that ignores a well-documented medical condition—isn’t about readiness. It is about exclusion.
Diminishing Women Who Serve
The new “male-level” physical standards are being promoted not as readiness but as a cultural purge. By implying that combat effectiveness requires every woman to meet the same numbers as the most physically gifted men, Hegseth effectively tells countless women who have served with distinction that they are somehow less than.
Women have led troops in combat, flown fighters in war zones, commanded ships at sea, and given their lives in uniform. They have shown courage under fire that no physical-fitness chart can measure. To dismiss their contribution as the product of a “politically correct” era is not only historically false, it is insulting.
Scripture tells us that in Christ there is neither male nor female, Jew nor Greek, slave nor free. Our military, too, has drawn strength from the diversity of those willing to serve. A standard that implicitly suggests women’s service is a concession to “wokeness” erases their courage and diminishes their sacrifice.
A Pastoral Word
If you feel uneasy about this shift, you’re not alone. Faith is not weakness. Compassion is not cowardice.
Jesus called peacemakers “blessed” for a reason. In times like these, our calling is to resist the normalization of cruelty, and to pray and act for a world where the strong defend the vulnerable rather than humiliate them.
A Prayer for Peace and Courage
Lord Jesus, Prince of Peace, give wisdom and humility to our leaders.
Strengthen those in uniform who serve with honor and sacrifice.
Guard the hearts of all who are tempted to mistake cruelty for strength.
Teach us to be peacemakers in a world quick to reach for the sword.
Amen.
Call to Action
How are you feeling about this? Let me know in the comments, I’d like to have a robust discussion.
And, If you believe in the Gospel call to be peacemakers, I invite you to stay connected with this community.
Subscribe to Message from the Margins to receive reflections, prayers, and resources that help us stay centered in the way of Christ even as the world grows harsher.